272 Delaware Avenue,
Put-in-Bay,
Ohio,
United States,
Ohio
“The hotel's location is perfect, just a short walk from the vibrant heart of downtown Put-In-Bay.”view full review
Commodore Resort offers a vibrant stay in Put-in-Bay with a seasonal outdoor swimming pool and multiple dining options, including the well-known Mr. Ed's Bar. This 3-star hotel provides a unique experience in the entertainment district with easy access to local nightlife.
Rooms & Amenities
The accommodations at Commodore Resort include a variety of room types, featuring king and double beds, some with Jacuzzi baths. All rooms are air-conditioned and equipped with flat-screen TVs. Guests may reserve cabanas by the pool and utilize lounge chairs free of charge.
Dining & Leisure
Dining options at Commodore Resort include two restaurants, with American cuisine served in Mr. Ed's Bar. The MIST Pool Bar offers a lively poolside experience, including a swim-up bar for guests seeking refreshment during their stay.
Location & Local Attractions
Commodore Resort is situated in the heart of the entertainment district, just a block from the downtown ferry. Guests have convenient access to local attractions such as Perry's Cave and DeRivera Park, with various restaurants and nightlife options within walking distance.
Entertainment & Services
The hotel features a nightclub, with The Green Room being the only second-story nightclub on the main strip. Guests can take advantage of the seasonal outdoor pool and sun terrace, while the shared lounge offers a relaxed environment for socializing.
View all
Select your room type
The hotel offers a variety of rooms including double rooms, family rooms, and suites with breakfast, free cancelations, and special deals
Explore a range of transportation options for your spa getaway
City Centre
Put-in-Bay700 ft
Airports
Toledo Express (TOL)
72.7
mi
Cleveland Hopkins International (CLE)
77.3
mi
Facilities
The hotel offers amenities for your comfortable stay and unforgettable experiences
Convenient Subway!
“The Subway restaurant located right in the lobby was perfect for quick meals, especially after a late night out.” view full review
Lively Pool Vibes
“The pool area was always buzzing with energy, featuring live DJs and a swim-up bar that made for an exciting and fun atmosphere.” view full review
Unique Flooring!
“I loved the vinyl wood flooring in the room, which felt much cleaner and more modern compared to typical carpeted hotel rooms.” view full review
Easy Golf Cart Rentals
“Renting a golf cart was a breeze with discounts available, making our exploration of the island super convenient.” view full review
General
Non-smoking rooms
Free Wi-Fi
24-hour reception
No pets allowed
Rooms/ Facilities for disabled
Wheelchair access
24-hour security
Adults only
Luggage storage
Locker room
Lift
ATM/Cash machine
Vending machines
Smoke detectors
Fire extinguishers
Key card access
Sports & Fitness
Golf course
Fishing
Services
Housekeeping
Tours/Ticket assistance
Welcome drink
Dining
Restaurant
Poolside snack bar
Picnic area/ Tables
Business
Meeting/ Banquet facilities
Fax/Photocopying
Facilities for people with disabilities
Toilet for disabled
Spa & Leisure
Seasonal outdoor pool
Sun loungers
Live entertainment
Night club
Sun terrace
Leisure/ TV room
Shallow end
Room features
Air conditioning
Heating
Garden furniture
Bathroom
Free toiletries
Media
Flat-screen TV
Room decor
Carpeted floor
Show more
Location
272 Delaware Avenue,
Put-in-Bay,
Ohio,
United States,
Ohio
Map view
272 Delaware Avenue,
Put-in-Bay,
Ohio,
United States,
Ohio
City landmarks
Monument
Perry's Victory and International Peace Memorial
2500 ft
Landmark
Stonehenge Estate
4000 ft
Landmark
Perry's Cave
3500 ft
Landmark
Chocolate Museum
2300 ft
Landmark
Aquatic Resource Center
2100 ft
Landmark
Alaskan Birdhouse Wildlife Museum
2100 ft
Landmark
Perry's Cave Family Fun Center
3800 ft
Landmark
Oak Point State Park
3600 ft
Botanical Garden
Butterfly House
3600 ft
Island
South Bass Island
1.1
mi
Landmark
South Bass Island Lighthouse
1.2
mi
Landmark
Scheeff East Point Preserve
1.0
mi
Island
Middle Bass Island
2.0
mi
Landmark
Middle Bass Island State Park
1.6
mi
Landmark
Starve Island
1.8
mi
Winery
Lonz Winery
2.0
mi
Landmark
Bass Islands
2.2
mi
Nearby
2 Bayside Ave
DeRivera Park
1600 ft
Restaurants
Put-in-Bay Pizza Company
1400 ft
439 Loraine Ave
Candy Bar
1600 ft
170 Delaware St
Village Bakery and Cafe
2100 ft
104 Delaware St
Reviews and Ratings
Feedback from previous guests about their experience.
Guest reviews
5.0/10
based on 5 reviews
4.6
4.6/10 based on 10 reviews
Penelope
United Kingdom,
January
2025
8.6/10
I had an amazing weekend getaway at the Commodore with its fun, lively atmosphere, and excellent access to local bars and restaurants. The rooms were generally clean and comfortable, but I noticed some minor issues that could be improved. The pool area was fantastic with engaging entertainment, but it's definitely a party place, so families looking for a quiet stay might want to choose another option. Overall, it was great value for an entertaining trip, especially with the late-night Subway right on-site for quick snacks.
Rooms
6.0
The room was mostly clean, but I had some concerns like cobwebs in the bathroom and hair in the shower that could be addressed. Also, a coffee maker would have been a nice touch to enhance the experience.
Service
9.0
The staff were welcoming and attentive throughout our stay, which made a difference in our overall enjoyment.
Location
10.0
The location is unbeatable! You're right in the heart of Put-In-Bay, making it super convenient to access numerous restaurants and nightlife without needing a golf cart.
Dining
Facilities
9.0
The pool area had a vibrant social scene, perfect for someone looking to party. The DJ events at the pool added to the fun atmosphere, making it a lively spot to hang out.
Justin
United Kingdom,
December
2024
7.0/10
The hotel is centrally located, which makes it very convenient for exploring Put-In-Bay's vibrant nightlife and activities. The room I stayed in was noisy and a bit underwhelming, especially since it was right next to a Subway restaurant, making it less than ideal. Being this close to the action has its perks, but I found the atmosphere to be overwhelming at times. The pool area was lively and fun, full of energy with a youthful crowd, which I appreciated, but it was also very crowded during peak times.
Rooms
5.0
The room I stayed in was spacious but lacked decor and soundproofing, located right next to the Subway, which was quite annoying.
Service
6.0
The service was a bit hit or miss; while I got my check-in done efficiently, the information from staff could often feel dismissive.
Location
10.0
I loved the location, it was right in the middle of everything, making it easy to walk to bars, restaurants, and the docks.
Dining
Facilities
7.0
The pool was nice and offered a party vibe, but it definitely got crowded, and the lack of heating was a downside.
Sebastian
United Kingdom,
November
2024
7.4/10
While the overall vibe at Commodore is lively and energetic, my stay was marred by a few below-par experiences. The location is very convenient for nightlife, and the pool area is a hotspot. However, I found my room lacking and felt disappointed with the amenities provided, making it not quite worth the price paid.
Rooms
5.0
The room was small and outdated, with issues like a deadbolt that didn't work initially, and a musty smell that lingered despite the effort to clean it. It felt cramped and was unfortunately located next to dumpsters, impacting the overall experience.
Service
6.0
The service was decent and they appeared to be investing in improvements like new mattresses, but there was a lack of attention to our comfort in terms of room assignments.
Location
9.0
The location is fantastic, right in the middle of all the action, making it easy to explore local bars and restaurants.
Dining
Facilities
7.0
The pool area was vibrant and engaging, a fun place to hang out, although it could have opened earlier as advertised.
Emma
United Kingdom,
October
2024
8.0/10
I had a lovely stay at this hotel, enjoying the upbeat vibe and social atmosphere, especially around the pool area. The rooms were clean and updated but lacked a few amenities that would elevate the experience. The presence of the Subway restaurant was a great perk for quick meals. However, some elements, like noise control and storage in the bathroom, could use some improvement.
Rooms
7.0
The rooms were clean and upgraded with laminate flooring, which made them feel more modern. However, they lacked some basic amenities like an iron and hooks in the bathroom.
Service
8.0
The service was attentive, and the staff was very welcoming, making my stay enjoyable overall.
Location
9.0
The location is fantastic, providing easy access to downtown Put-In-Bay and various entertainment spots.
Dining
8.0
Having the Subway on-site was a great convenience for quick breakfasts and snacks throughout the day.
Facilities
8.0
The pool area was vibrant and lively, perfect for a party-oriented getaway, though the noise could get a bit loud during peak hours.
Mia
United Kingdom,
October
2024
6.8/10
We had a lively stay at this resort, enjoying the vibrant atmosphere around the pool and the convenience of the Subway right in the lobby. The rooms were a bit dated and felt smaller than expected, but they were cleaned daily, which was a plus. The dining options were quite limited, and the surrounding noise from the pool could get overwhelming at times. However, the location is central to everything, making it easy to enjoy the nightlife of Put-In-Bay.
Rooms
6.0
The rooms were a bit dated and smaller than I had hoped, but cleaned daily.
Service
7.0
The service was decent but had some hiccups during check-in.
Location
9.0
The hotel is centrally located, close to bars and restaurants, perfect for nightlife.
Dining
5.0
Dining was limited; I would have liked more breakfast choices.
Facilities
7.0
The pool area had a fun vibe, but the noise level was quite high.
Want to see exclusive early booking offers?
Access special rates now and plan your next wellness retreat!
Pueblo Bonito Emerald Luxury Villas & Spa All Inclusive
Pacific Shores Resort & Spa
Cygnett Resort Mountain Breeze
The Pavilions Phuket (Adults Only)
Sunrise Garden Beach Resort
Chateau Royal Beach Resort & Spa, Noumea
Kata Palm Resort - Sha Plus
Amara Resort Hua Hin
Binh An Village Vung Tau
Salamandra Hotel
Kensington Resort Seorak Beach
Mascot Hotel Senggigi